|
Community Top 10 adventure games of the 2020-2025 - Printable Version +- Adventure Game Hotspot Community (https://community.adventuregamehotspot.com) +-- Forum: Games Discussion (https://community.adventuregamehotspot.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Adventure Games (https://community.adventuregamehotspot.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Community Top 10 adventure games of the 2020-2025 (/showthread.php?tid=424) |
Community Top 10 adventure games of the 2020-2025 - Joe - 12-15-2025 ![]() And the winners are: Rules: RE: Community Top 10 adventure games 2020-2025 - srnickolas - 12-15-2025 top10 (yeah this is probably mixed the more I think the more I switch places so i just put these lists on impulse) 1. The Legend of Skye 2. Lair of the Clockwork God 3. Paranormasight: The Seven Mysteries of Honjo 4. The Great Ace Attorney Chronicles (English release) 5. Foolish Mortals 6. Urban Witch Story 7. You're Watching Icebox! 8. Kathy Rain 2: Soothsayer 9. Lucy Dreaming 10. The Will of Arthur Flabbington Honorable mentions Hyperdrive Inn Emio – The Smiling Man: Famicom Detective Club (haven't finished yet but seems very good so far) The Abandoned Planet The Excavation of Hob's Barrow Crowns and Pawns: Kingdom of Deceit Mutropolis LumineNight Mothmen 1966 An English Haunting Murders on the Yangtze River The Drifter The Witch's Lullaby Loco Motive NORCO No Case Should Remain Unsolved The Case of the Golden Idol (+DLC) Yet Another Killing Game The Telwynium James Peris 2: The fountain of eternal drunkenness Submachine: Legacy (remaster of older games released in 2023, I don't know if it can be here if not ignore) Prim Midnight Scenes: A Safe Place Beyond Shadowgate D3ad Hand Slender Threads The Hand of Glory AI: The Somnium Files - Nirvana Initiative VirtuaVerse Papetura Not Another Weekend Shards of God Nightmare Frames Strangeland Riddlewood Manor Spirit Hunter: Death Mark II Luna The Shadow Dust Leisure Suit Larry - Wet Dreams Dry Twice Jesus I'll stop here Dishonorable mentions: I'll agree with The Adventures of the Black Hawk and add Crowalt: Traces of the Lost Colony which literally was a mess in almost every way (the UI, gameplay, graphics, crude progression, bugs ...). I played other games i found underwhelming but the reason I mention this title is cause it got a 4/5 star in The adventure gamers site that I cannot begin to grasp, an opinion is an opinion but that game was so amateurish and originally was sold for 10 bucks, it just left me speechless RE: Community Top 10 adventure games 2020-2025 - LeftHandedGuitarist - 12-15-2025 I'm a patient gamer that tends to be several years behind on new releases, so I've actually only played this handful of adventure games from the 2020s. Here's how I'd rank them: (UPDATED 24/12)
Honourable mention: Lake If On A Winter's Night, Four Travelers Dogwalk RE: Community Top 10 adventure games 2020-2025 - Joe - 12-15-2025 (12-15-2025, 03:37 PM)srnickolas Wrote: 1. The Legend of Sky
RE: Community Top 10 adventure games 2020-2025 - srnickolas - 12-15-2025 Yeah my fellow co-adventurer, this game ticked all the right buttons inside indeed
RE: Community Top 10 adventure games 2020-2025 - Joshua AGH - 12-15-2025 If you think this is a tough choice, wait until you see the project our staff is currently working on. Because of that, I can't make my choices public just yet but I've got a TON of things to say on this
RE: Community Top 10 adventure games 2020-2025 - Dryade - 12-16-2025 Here's my list. I haven't played The Drifter yet, and from everything I've heard I suspect it would be in it, but as of now: 1. Foolish Mortals 2. Markus Ritter - Ghosts of the Past (Super fringe, I know, but I miss Point and Click FMV's like Gabriel Knight 2 and Phantasmagoria) 3. If On A Winter's Night, Four Travelers (Incredibly underrated free game) 4. Broken Sword - Shadow of the Templars: Reforged 5. Loco Motive 6. The Crimson Diamond 7. The Legend of Skye 8. Nightmare Frames 9. An English Haunting 10. The Excavation of Hob's Barrow Honorable mentions: Cleo - a pirate's tale Lucy Dreaming Pentiment Slender Threads Elroy and the Aliens The Beekeeper's Picnic Markus Ritter - The Lost Family Rosewater 3 minutes to Midnight Old Skies Unusual Findings The Will of Arthur Flabbington Prim Dark Nights with Poe and Munro Dishonorable mention: Wolf Among Us 2, where are you??? RE: Community Top 10 adventure games 2020-2025 - Baron Blubba - 12-16-2025 1. Lucy Dreaming - The character, the story, the writing, the graphics, the gameplay. As good as it gets. 2. Legend of Skye - The very challenging but fair gameplay had me up late at night and then thinking about it while trying to fall asleep and then waking me up in the middle of the night to try a solution I dreamed about. Great world full of memorable characters and scenes. 3. The Phantom Fellows - It's classic 'n cozy by-the-numbers adventure gaming, yet there's nothing else like it. Superlatively entertaining script.The only flaw is the cliffhanger ending and maybe one dud of a pixel hunt. 4. Lost in Play - It made me smile, laugh, and take screenshots to share with family and friends. A great time from start to finish, pure feel-good entertainment with a perfect challenge level. 5. There Is No Game: Wrong Dimension - I had no idea what to expect from this game. Thought I'd hate it due to its smug hipster meta-ness. Eventually heard enough praise for it that I decided to give it a try. And was blown away. Like Lost In Play, this is a game that will entertain and make you feel good. It's conceptually brilliant without ever not being fun. Except for one part where the game forgets the very important rule that The Game That Spoofs A Boring Gameplay Loop From Another Game Should Be Very Careful Not To Become Boring Itself. Other than that one section, There Is No Game is the best game that never was. 6. Norco - Compelling plot that is exceptionally well written. Atmospherically evocative like almost nothing else, thanks to coalescence of all the elements: Words, graphics, music, and gameplay. 7. Foolish Mortals - Very close to the perfect Lucas Arts game that never was. Only let down by the amount of explain-away exposition toward the end of the game and the classic dumb saw-it-coming-a-lifetime-away trope of 'hero does all the work, bad guy emerges and capitalizes on it at the end.' It also talks too much: While all of the writing is good, there's too much of it. 8. Wildwood Down - In my heart, this game is in the top 5. I've never played anything like it in terms of setting or character. And it's the only adventure game that looks like Parappa the Rapper! If not for a couple of glitchy sections (which I believe have since been fixed) and one or two moments of questionable puzzle design (in a game full of great puzzle design!), it would have rated higher. 9. Darkside Detective: A Fumble in the Dark - Breezy enough to be breezy, challenging enough to make you feel smarter than Dooley, funny enough to make you squirt ectoplasm out your nose. It does everything it sets out to do perfectly. 10. Return to Monkey Island - I really want to rank this one higher. I reviewed it for the Hotspot and had very few complaints. In fact, it might be my favorite Monkey Island after Curse of Monkey Island! Honorable Mentions 1st Class (no particular order): Beyond the Edge of Owlsgard - Would have probably been a top ten game, but the last 25% was a letdown. Not bad, but a big step down from the initial greatness. Azazel's Christmas Fable - I stayed away from this game because Christmas themed media usually turns me off. Eventually I read enough good things about it and it was on sale, so I finally ended up playing it in December of 2025. It's a fantastic traditional point 'n click adventure that made me laugh a lot and think just enough. Completely charming. This could probably make my top 10 list if I really wanted to go back and edit that, which I don't. You could totally hate Christmas and still love this game. Play it! Cleo: A Pirates Tale - A cute top-down adventure game with a great piratey theme, a good plot, fun puzzles, and likable characters. It purports to be 'Zelda-ish' but it's not --it's pure adventure, through and through. The Drifter - While it couldn't maintain the sheer force of awesomeness that carried the first half of the game full speed ahead like a freight train, the rest of the game was still good enough to ALMOST land The Drifter on my top 10 list. Crimson Diamond - I loved this game, wish I could put it in my top 10 but I enjoyed all those *just a smidge* more. An English Haunting - This is my favorite game by Post Modern Adventures and it hurts a little to not have it in my Top 10. Brilliant writing and voice acting, with the perfect level of difficulty that makes you feel like you are still playing a game, but doesn't get in the way of the story moving forward. Nightmare Frames - Not into horror but thoroughly enjoyed this one, despite being pretty gruesome and I guess you could say scary. From the creator of An English Haunting. Urban Witch Story - Great presentation of a slice of life from a real night in American history. Primitive graphics convey the time and place perfectly, and even the sometimes poor translation adds character. Also from the developer of An English Haunting. Excavation of Hob's Barrow - Phenomenal atmosphere, great characterization. Classic point and click goodness! Kathy Rain 2: Soothsayer - Wasn't a fan of the first game (it was merely 'ok' at best), and was ready to be the contrarian who would slate this game, too. Alas, it's too good. One of the best classic point and clicks of the last few years, for sure. Seance of Blake Manor - Only played a few hours of this. I suspect that if I'd finished it, it would end up in the top 10, but it's too in depth for me at the moment. Roki - Remarkably heartfelt game overcame a few small design flaws and won me over entirely. A world to get lost in, containing a mystery with answers worth finding. True Fear: Forsaken Souls series (multiple parts, final part came out in 2025 so I'm counting it) - Beneath the Hidden Object veneer, find one of the most satisfying inventory based puzzle games of recent memory. The story is very good but goes a little crazy toward the end. I recommend NOT playing all the games one after another, as the excellent gameplay will become repetitive. Virtuaverse - I wish I could have included this severely underrated game in my top 10. Amazing graphics and music, a unique world and story, and some 90's-difficulty level puzzles that are *mostly* fair with just a couple of eye-rolling duds. Honorable Mentions 2nd Class: Rosewater - Good but disappointing. I didn't care for most of the characters, and I don't like choice based games that find a way to reprimand the player no matter which choice they make (perhaps in a display of 'even handed' characterization). I want to play THE story, not some mottled version of the story based on what choices I made, based on the mood I was currently in, based on whether that day I feel like playing as myself or as I think the main character would act. Locomotive - Probably the best visual comedy of any adventure game I can remember...since Monkey Island 3, at least!. Unfortunately, I got bored replaying the same events from different perspectives; and many of the puzzles, while they worked, just weren't fun to do. Slender Threads - Nothing fancy about this one, just a solid breezy-cozy adventure game with cool graphics. Elroy and the Aliens - An enjoyable romp! If you like point and clickers, you'll have a good time. Voodoo Detective - Like Slender Threads, this game won't blow you away, but it will thoroughly entertain you for a while with good puzzles, characters, and writing. LATE ADDITION: The Will of Arthur Flabbington. - Almost finished this one. Not quite good enough to make my top 10, but it's very funny, has a very solid old-fashioned challenge, and overall I'm enjoying it much more than I thought I would. Thanks to Joshua for mentioning this on one of his top games lists, otherwise I would have probably ignored it. Honorable Mentions with No Class: Brownie's Adventure Brownie's Adventure 2 The first one was better, but I enjoyed both. Are they 'good games'? I don't know. But they made me laugh a lot and think a little, simultaneously growing and slaughtering my brain cells at the same time. That's quite an accomplishment, so the games get mentioned. RE: Community Top 10 adventure games 2020-2025 - MenhirMike - 12-16-2025 This is so tough to rank... 01. The Crimson Diamond 02. Ace Attorney Investigations 2 03. The Case of the Golden Idol 04. The Excavation of Hob's Barrow 05. Lucy Dreaming 06. BROK the InvestiGator 07. Perfect Tides 08. Riven (Remake) 09. Yes, Your Grace 10. The Forgotten City Honorable Mention to Foolish Mortal, not ranking it because recency bias. RE: Community Top 10 adventure games 2020-2025 - Karlok - 12-17-2025 1 Blue Prince 2 The Case of the Golden Idol 3 IMMORTALITY 4 There Is No Game 5 Chants of Sennaar 6 The Roottrees Are Dead 7 Pentiment 8 The Longing 9 The Drifter 10 Riven Remake Honourable mentions: Excavation of Hobs’s Barrow – Mindlock: The Apartment – Beyond the Edge of Owlsgard – The Crimson Diamond |