Adventure Game Hotspot Community
Working on a Lovecraftian mystery game — would this art style put you off? - Printable Version

+- Adventure Game Hotspot Community (https://community.adventuregamehotspot.com)
+-- Forum: Games Discussion (https://community.adventuregamehotspot.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Adventure Games (https://community.adventuregamehotspot.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Working on a Lovecraftian mystery game — would this art style put you off? (/showthread.php?tid=824)



Working on a Lovecraftian mystery game — would this art style put you off? - nektrus - 11-11-2026

Hi,

I'm working on a Lovecraft-inspired adventure game set in Arkham and wanted to ask for some honest feedback on the visuals.

I'm posting one screenshot from the game. I'm trying to keep it moody and unsettling, but I'm not sure if the current look is actually appealing enough for players, or if it just feels too flat.

Would a game looking like this catch your attention as an adventure game?

What would you improve first?


RE: Working on a Lovecraftian mystery game — would this art style put you off? - Piero - 11-11-2026

It looks suitably moody for a horror game, and although it doesn't jump out at me it does look intriguing.

Is it AI generated? I only ask because it's a question everyone will be asking, and some elements do look a bit wrong: the position of the chest of drawers near the door, or the two swords above the painting, for example.


RE: Working on a Lovecraftian mystery game — would this art style put you off? - nektrus - 11-11-2026

Thanks for the feedback!

No AI involved. Our artist draws everything by hand, and a single scene takes her around 40 hours to complete.

There's actually only one sabre above the painting, not two swords. And the unusual placement of the cabinet is intentional — there's a hidden compartment underneath it that plays a part in the mystery. Smile

The artwork also looks much better at its original resolution, as some of the finer details get lost in screenshots.

Glad you found the atmosphere intriguing, though. That's definitely what we're going for!


RE: Working on a Lovecraftian mystery game — would this art style put you off? - Piero - 11-11-2026

In that case - I'm impressed! I'm not fundamentally against use of AI - but it is always good to know when it's not used, and I do MUCH prefer hand made drawings. The artist is very talented!

Then I'd like to add some more helpful feedback.. the sword does look a little like it's broken in the middle (but maybe that's your nod to Broken Sword!) Overall, I really like the colour palette although I find the heavy green outlining from the back-light a bit of a clichéd look. For me it could just do with one or two more accent colours - maybe they will be introduced with the game characters, right?

Overall - 9/10 from me Smile


RE: Working on a Lovecraftian mystery game — would this art style put you off? - nektrus - 11-11-2026

Thanks, 9/10 is more than I expected! Smile

I'll pass your comments on to our artist, especially the point about the green lighting and accent colours.

And no, the sabre wasn't meant as a Broken Sword reference, but now I almost wish it was!

Really appreciate you taking the time to look at the details.


RE: Working on a Lovecraftian mystery game — would this art style put you off? - Jen - 11-11-2026

The mood of the scene is appropriate for a horror game. It’s dark without making the individual items indistinguishable. The door could be moved a little to the right so that the chest fits better. Also, the perspective is off on the table with the papers on the right side. Fixing this would immediately add dimension to the scene. I look forward to seeing what you come up with Smile


RE: Working on a Lovecraftian mystery game — would this art style put you off? - BobVP - 11-11-2026

It's good! The interface looks clean as well.


RE: Working on a Lovecraftian mystery game — would this art style put you off? - nektrus - 11-11-2026

Thanks everyone for the feedback! I really appreciate you taking the time to look at the details.

Jen, good catch on the table perspective. I'll pass that on to our artist. And thanks, Bob! Glad you like the UI too.

We actually have a playable demo on Steam if anyone's curious. Happy to share the link, but I don't want to turn this thread into an advertisement.

Thanks again for all the comments, they're genuinely helpful!