PIEDRA_Adventure_Gaming   11-16-2026, 08:47 PM  
#1
Some puzzles aren't solved by looking, but by listening: a melody you have to repeat, a code made of sounds, a clue that only exists in your ears.

I think they stick with us because there are no shortcuts. You can stare at a screen for as long as you like; a sound happens and then it's gone. Either you pay attention or you don't get through.

The one I've always found brilliant is Loom: its spells are melodies, and some of them, played backwards, do the exact opposite.

I've spent weeks on this topic for a video about music that lives inside the story in adventure games. Leaving it here in case anyone's interested (it's in Spanish, with subtitles in several languages): https://youtu.be/pIv54tPnHgI

But what I'd really like is to hear from you:

- Which audio puzzle do you remember most, and from which game? The piano in The 7th Guest? The sounds in Myst?
- Did you solve it by ear, with pen and paper, or with a walkthrough?
- Are they among the best things in the genre, or a nightmare if you don't have a musical ear?

Wild Boar   11-16-2026, 09:17 PM  
#2
The only one I remind is in The Lost Crown and I always solve it by walkthrough.
Piero   11-16-2026, 09:49 PM  
#3
There's an area in The Witness where the line puzzles are solved by listening for very subtle sounds in the environment.
arcanetrivia   11-16-2026, 09:57 PM  
#4
In Tales of Monkey Island you have to follow a map by listening for certain animal sounds at the exits of the screen. Interesting concept, but even as a hearing person I've sometimes found it hard to distinguish the sounds, and there's no recourse for a person who's actually deaf - they'd just be completely stuck, or I guess stuck brute-forcing and saving on every screen (the cue for when you've made a successful move is also audio-only, although iirc there is a visual cue when you did it wrong?).
Estória   11-16-2026, 10:24 PM  
#5
King's Quest 7 had a harp that you had to play by ear. The melody from that has always stuck with me.
kamineko   11-16-2026, 11:20 PM  
#6
Ugh, the musical tone puzzle in Bosworth Clark's lab in Tex Murphy: Overseer.

Had to bring in a friend to solve it for me.
Dryade   11-17-2026, 01:37 AM  
#7
It's funny that the Tales of Monkey Island puzzle has been mentioned already, because that definitely stuck with me the most. I almost always play games without sound, as I need to be quiet and find most voice acting to be abysmal anyways. I was trying to find my way in the jungle, and I did not know at all that I was supposed to be a sound based puzzle, so I was trying to spot some (inexistent) visual clue. I wandered around for hours and many nights before consulting a walkthrough and facepalmed hard.
rtrooney   11-17-2026, 02:09 AM  
#8
There were several sound puzzles in MYST. I needed help on all of them.

For whom the games toll ...
They toll for thee
Piero   11-17-2026, 10:07 AM  
#9
(11-17-2026, 02:09 AM)rtrooney Wrote: There were several sound puzzles in MYST. I needed help on all of them.

I'm playing Myst for the first time right now and came across the first of those sound puzzles last night. The funny thing is how the sounds are just basic beeps and buzzes, compared to the (for the time) lavish graphics. I haven't solved the puzzle yet though.
LadyKestrel   11-17-2026, 03:16 PM  
#10
I found using headphones made a difference in the Myst underground transport maze and also when following the lemur through the jungle in the second Agon episode, The Pirates of Madagascar.

You're never too old to play in leaves.
  
Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)