Monkey Island 2 is iconic and has my vote. Love the colours, love the composition. One of my all-time favourites.

I prefer this version of LᵉChuck’s Revenge Monkey Island 2. All that drama with the colours, the dark and the light. Really fits the scene.

Indiana Jones is like a mood board. It does create an atmosphere. Sophia deserved better. Is that camel rider flipping off the ones in pursuit? I mean that's pretty cool, but it also seems like a misconception of priorities.

I vote Monkey Island 2.

MI2. Very stylish artistically.

The Indy box is beautiful enough, but nothing about it says "Atlantis" to me. I mean, camels? C'mon.

Monkey Island 2.
It looks and feels like an "old masters" painting.
Beautiful, moody, much more than just a game box art.

Ahhhh this is tough. Both are so good. I want to say Indy, because this looks like an Indy poster, but...

I gotta go with MI2. It really is a colorful, beautiful design.

Indy is almost there, but it's missing a little bit of something I can't put my finger on. Like it's 90% finished, and the camels are awkward.

These are both really, really good! I'm going to go with Indiana Jones: Fate of Atlantis for this one, which just barely wins over MI2 for me.

I choose Indiana Jones and the Fate of Atlantis.

Another tough one. It's hard not to compare my feelings for the games, themselves, when judging the artwork. But, a choice must be made. Fate of Atlantis is my winner in this round.

Monkey Island 2 for me !

MI2 for sure. FoA does the job but it's not special