Monkey Island 2! I love this so much that I've got this hanging on my wall as a huge poster.

Monkey Island 2! Pretty iconic and looks fantastic.

MI2 is one of the best pieces of box art in all of gaming IMO. Easy choice.

Both are great, but I'm going to vote for Indy. I was never a big fan of MI2's cover art.

MI2 wins 17-8!

Next match:



 Vote!

Day of the Tentacle gets my vote.

Interesting match-up! They both have similarities: a slimy creature and person(s) moving forward in the same direction and similar-ish fonts.

Mortimer looks like the cover of a kid-friendly storybook, while Tentacle looks like its older, darker, black-comedy counterpart. Both are nice and appropriate for their respective target audiences.

My vote goes to Tentacle!

Day of the tentacle

Peter Chan's full illustration for DOTT is so good, but for some strange reason they only used a small part of it for the cover, taking away a lot of its magic. But I still prefer its darker tone, so my vote goes to DOTT.

Day of the Tentacle