Uh ... "The Cat Lady" has four different endings as well. It is a very dark and surreal horror game, I don't know if you would like it.
I was fascinated by the atmosphere and voiceover, it was a very unique game. I definitely liked it more than "Silence" which I mentioned before, but that is totally a matter of taste. Which is why I mentioned Silence at all, although it is not really one of my own favorites. I focused more on the "different endings" aspect.

I don't need different endings myself when looking for a good new adventure, but I understand why you like them.