Both fantastic, but I'm picking MI2 for the extra depth.

Monkey Island 2.

MI2 wins 14-7!

And here we are! The grand Finals.... Monkey Island 2 vs Sam & Max!



Who will prevail?




 Vote!

MI2. It’s a more composed piece of art.

They're both fantastic, but it's MI2 for me.

Monkey Island 2, only because the expression on LeChuck's face is priceless. He hates Guybrush so much.

Its a tough one but...Monkey Island 2.

Sam & Max

Out of the two it's Monkey Island 2.

I'd honestly be very happy with either, but since that's not how votes work... Monkey Island 2. Timeless, beautiful, and captures the imagination!

Thanks for running this again, Rubacava. It has been a whole lot of fun stroking the beard, furrowing the brow, and making hard choices.