Pages (4):    1 2 3 4   
Dryade   11-13-2026, 09:46 PM  
#21
If we are all out of work and do not have a source of income because all intellectual properties are stolen by LLMs, we'll all die of starvation/lack of shelter/etc. People value human lives more than natural resources, understandably so.
This post was last modified: 11-13-2026, 09:53 PM by Dryade.
arcanetrivia   11-14-2026, 06:30 AM  
#22
I'm..... not so sure that is actually the case.
Jackal   11-14-2026, 04:43 PM  
#23
I actually think there's room for optimism that adventure games will help the industry find its equilibrium in an AI world. I said some of this in the podcast Joshua mentioned (no one has missed it, because it's not out yet Wink), but it bears repeating here.

Our genre will have to deal with its fair share of AI clutter too, but good adventure games have always been highly bespoke. By that I mean they're reliant on hand-crafted production and creative implementation and integration of story and puzzles that all but demand human design. That makes them harder to make, and make well, but that will become more and more valued as the industry becomes increasingly saturated by AI.

It's funny, but I kind of see the adventure genre being an industry bellwether. It led the way in innovation and mainstream success, then led the way in crashing out of big-budget production and going indie (which the rest of the industry has only recently begun to experience more acutely). And now I see it leading the way in producing high-end human-made games that will become more and more cherished in an expanding sea of slop.

None of that reduces the challenge facing us in the meantime. But I hope that the Hotspot is at least one bulwark against the onslaught. Believe me, if you knew how much crap I have to wade through just to get to the games we add to the website each month, you'd be amazed. (Or not amazed, just nauseous.)

Co-founder, Editor-in-Chief, Adventure Game Hotspot (perhaps you've heard of it?)
Octavi Navarro   11-14-2026, 06:26 PM  
#24
Exactly. Adventure games is the only genre I trust for finding games made by humans, and sites like this are all I need to find the ones that are worth playing.

Other than that, the more studios embrace AI the less interested I am in buying new releases (except from trusted developers). I just don't have the time or energy to investigate if this game or that game was made with the slop machine. I prefer spending my time and money on pre-2025 games.

This is very unfair to legitimate new developers but this is the kind of harm AI is doing to our industry.
This post was last modified: 11-15-2026, 09:24 AM by Octavi Navarro.
BehindTimes   11-15-2026, 06:43 PM  
#25
(11-12-2026, 05:14 AM)PopPunkParty Wrote: However, on the coding side it's a little different. 

I just can't agree with this take.  Maybe it's because I'm a software developer, I don't know.  And I know a lot of software developers are split between the Hate AI and Love AI camps. There is a large contingent of programmers who see the programming as art, and I'll admit, I'm in this group.

You'll usually get people who say there's a differentiation between programming and something like painting or music as saying, well, there's only one way to write a for loop.  (Just go with the premise here, as yes, many languages have multiple ways of writing for loops, and there are many languages themselves).  But just like there's only one way to play a note or paint a line.  They're all building blocks.

Nor is the code itself as digital as people would like to believe.  Decades ago, you needed the code to be efficient.  Then when computers got fast enough and storage large enough, you wanted the code to be maintainable and easy to read and work with.  If you're after pure efficiency, the code is not going to look pretty nor be maintainable.

In the end, the program is the representation of the author(s).  And often times, it's because of lack of knowledge or even some flaws in logic or bugs that add new gameplay elements that become accepted.

Imperfection of humans leads to innovation, even in programming.

Now, there are a ton of other issues that will arise when leaving programming to AI, but that's not relevant to the conversation.

The major concession I'll make though is that AI is going to have to be accepted, whether we like it or not, because it is happening in all aspects, and is never going away.  And I'll even concede that it can program better, paint better, play music better, etc.  But like CGI, it leaves an uncanny valley.  And CGI hasn't fixed that in over 3 decades, and I don't see AI being any different.  The imperfection of the artist is what gives the work its soul, and that's something that machines just cannot do.  Being perfect feels wrong.  And even when they try to simulate imperfection, they're still perfect at being imperfect.
ethansmith   11-15-2026, 07:33 PM  
#26
The useful line isn't hand-written versus AI-assisted code; it's whether a human can explain, review, and maintain the result. AI can handle boilerplate, tests, and mechanical refactors when someone checks it, but opaque generated systems shift risk onto future maintainers. And the happy accidents that become gameplay usually come from playtesting and design intent, not from code generation alone. I'd keep human authorship where the implementation is inseparable from the game's feel.
rtrooney   11-15-2026, 07:54 PM  
#27
I like this. (BehindTime's post. While I was typing away, someone else responded before me.)

But, i still doesn't address the touchy subject of compensation. I personally believe it might be a non -issue. Because if AI companies ever were forced to justly compensate every entity that was used to train AI, the cost would possibly be insurmountable. And by every, I mean "every"! Think of it like a residual cost. The songwriter's payment doesn't end when he/she turns the song over to the publisher. He/she gets paid every time the music is played. Or, more to the point, if OpenAI "learned" by "reading" every article ever printed by the New York Times, then every word created by OpenAI means it owes NYT a royalty payment.
This post was last modified: 11-15-2026, 07:57 PM by rtrooney.

For whom the games toll ...
They toll for thee
Piero   11-15-2026, 08:02 PM  
#28
Compensation maybe an option in some cases. But if you've ever used AI for something useful to you - and I'm willing to bet that most of us have - you've essentially already given your consent to how they trained their models.
rtrooney   11-17-2026, 02:16 AM  
#29
I would hazard a guess that most of the people who use AI, other than for commercial use, don't have a clue how the AI models are trained. Lets alone have the knowledge to give informed consent.
This post was last modified: 11-17-2026, 02:19 AM by rtrooney.

For whom the games toll ...
They toll for thee
Octavi Navarro   11-17-2026, 08:39 AM  
#30
For me, using GenAI in the way it's commercialized today is 100% unethical in all cases, but my anger lies on the companies who steal for profit, not on the home user that doesn't even know how the technology works.
In any case, if compensating all the people who are being robbed is impossible, I'd be fine with forcing these companies to pay a 10% extra tax to every country where they commercialize their crap and direct that money towards funding the arts, or public hospitals, or anything that *truly* improves people's lives.
This post was last modified: 11-17-2026, 08:40 AM by Octavi Navarro.
Pages (4):    1 2 3 4   
  
Users browsing this thread: