Some puzzles aren't solved by looking, but by listening: a melody you have to repeat, a code made of sounds, a clue that only exists in your ears.
I think they stick with us because there are no shortcuts. You can stare at a screen for as long as you like; a sound happens and then it's gone. Either you pay attention or you don't get through.
The one I've always found brilliant is Loom: its spells are melodies, and some of them, played backwards, do the exact opposite.
I've spent weeks on this topic for a video about music that lives inside the story in adventure games. Leaving it here in case anyone's interested (it's in Spanish, with subtitles in several languages): https://youtu.be/pIv54tPnHgI
But what I'd really like is to hear from you:
- Which audio puzzle do you remember most, and from which game? The piano in The 7th Guest? The sounds in Myst?
- Did you solve it by ear, with pen and paper, or with a walkthrough?
- Are they among the best things in the genre, or a nightmare if you don't have a musical ear?
I think they stick with us because there are no shortcuts. You can stare at a screen for as long as you like; a sound happens and then it's gone. Either you pay attention or you don't get through.
The one I've always found brilliant is Loom: its spells are melodies, and some of them, played backwards, do the exact opposite.
I've spent weeks on this topic for a video about music that lives inside the story in adventure games. Leaving it here in case anyone's interested (it's in Spanish, with subtitles in several languages): https://youtu.be/pIv54tPnHgI
But what I'd really like is to hear from you:
- Which audio puzzle do you remember most, and from which game? The piano in The 7th Guest? The sounds in Myst?
- Did you solve it by ear, with pen and paper, or with a walkthrough?
- Are they among the best things in the genre, or a nightmare if you don't have a musical ear?
In Tales of Monkey Island you have to follow a map by listening for certain animal sounds at the exits of the screen. Interesting concept, but even as a hearing person I've sometimes found it hard to distinguish the sounds, and there's no recourse for a person who's actually deaf - they'd just be completely stuck, or I guess stuck brute-forcing and saving on every screen (the cue for when you've made a successful move is also audio-only, although iirc there is a visual cue when you did it wrong?).