This is tough but I gotta go with Beast Within. It's pretty stylish and I've always loved the minimalist look

My vote goes to Beast Within, pretty scary and sets the mood perfectly for the game.

The Beast Within wins 9-4!!

 Next match:



 Vote!

Mystery House.

Both - very cool.

Curious: neither box describes the game as an adventure! KQ5 is an "experience" and Mystery House is an AVENTURE.

Despite this, I'm going with the highest level of adventurousness. And I really like the font of the title.

King's Quest V.

King's Quest V

KQ5 is a great composition, but a bit generic imho. Mystery house great composition and the little things happening on every room too cool. Also love both title fonts in their styles.

Voting Mystery House.

I like both of those but Mystery House gets my vote.

KQ V. 
Iconic!

Both are interesting. Going to vote for King's Quest V, it promises adventure!