I choose the Space Quest cover. Pepper's Adventures in Time is way too busy and crowded.

Space Quest

Space Quest for me, too. That Pepper one is ugly and garish like the ugly and garish LSL ones from earlier.

Whenever I see these boxes I have two responses, the first being me as a kid with a box in each hand. The second is more based what I'd consider aesthetically good or fun at this point in time.

In this case, Pepper calls out to young me and for once I'm going to go with that.

Pepper's Adventures is crowded, but it makes the game look fun. The Space Quest cover makes it seem like a cold, somber experience. I vote for Pepper on this one.

Aaaand Space quest 1 wins 9-4!! Next match is:



 Vote!

It's a little scary, but

THE BEAST WITHIN

I vote for Gabriel Knight 2. I hear a lot of praise for it and while I do not overly like it, the quest for glory one has a pretty big frame.. and then another frame. That's too much framing for me.

The Beast Within. Super evocative.

I do like the QfG2 art, though I do think it ought to have taken up more space on the box.

However... The Beast Within is just such an amazing piece of art! It feels both minimalistic and not at the same time, it accurately represents the premise of the story... Just absolutely beautiful! And this is the second of all thus far I'd easily hang on my wall just by the quality of the art alone.