Boxblue Studios 01-04-2026, 06:30 PM
Considering that both Ryan and I regard Broken Sword 1 and 2 as virtual masterpieces of point-and-click adventure history, we’ve never really given the following two episodes a fair crack of the whip.
I first tried Broken Sword 3: The Sleeping Dragon on its original release, but never got very far. A combination of blocky 3D graphics, awkward camera angles, and frustrating controls saw my attempts to thwart the Sleeping Dragon quickly ebb away until, eventually, I stopped playing altogether. When Broken Sword 4: The Angel of Death arrived a few years later, I didn’t even bother to check it out... the memory of the third episode had been that disappointing.
Now, with a few more years behind me and a shift in focus from player to player-creator, I decided it was time to give it another go. The fact that it was on sale on GOG didn’t hurt either...
So, twenty-odd years later, I finally finished the game. Below are my thoughts.
What a shock to the system those basic 3D models were back in 2003. With the benefit of a couple of decades, however, they’re not quite as bad as I remember. Well… not quite anyway.
The first thing I noticed this time around was the silky tones of Rolf Saxon, once again providing the personality of our everyman hero, George Stobbart. Nico Collard, unfortunately, didn’t enjoy the same continuity. In this instalment she’s voiced by Sarah Crook, who nonetheless does a good job of injecting her with some much-needed personality. With our leads established, the game can begin — but first, let’s head back to those graphics.
I actually liked the 3D model for George. His face and expressions felt like a strong 3D interpretation of his classic 2D look. He emoted well, and even his stubble was nicely handled (especially when contrasted with the higher-resolution but oddly worse face model in Broken Sword 4).
Nico, however, was not so lucky. Leaving aside for the moment her massive, sealed-at-the-end nostrils, there were so many issues with her arms and legs that I started to suspect she’d once been involved in a locomotive crash and escaped hospital before being properly discharged. Hands twisted at impossible angles, a neck that seemed only loosely attached to her head, and even her 90s flared trousers couldn’t contain those janky feet. It was obvious far more care had been taken with George’s model, something that extended to most of the supporting cast (Petra especially). None of this is game-breaking, the comfortable cushion of “playing an old game” helps a lot, but it reminded me exactly why I wasn’t impressed the first time around.
Thankfully, the game itself tells a solid story spanning several continents, as you’d expect. I enjoyed poking around a hugely empty Glastonbury (if only the real Glastonbury was as easy to get around), where I felt some of the game’s best puzzles lived, and the Congo sections had a nice overall feel, injecting a bit of classic Indy-style exploration. Puzzles that required both characters to work in tandem were a great addition, and I particularly liked the tiled floor puzzle in the Omega Temple section.
However… crates.
With the success of Tomb Raider and other 3D adventure games, a lot of time here is spent pushing crates backwards and forwards. I mean, really a lot. At first it was a novelty, “Okay, this is new for a Broken Sword game.” Eventually, though, every time I entered a new area and spotted a crate, I would tense up and expect the worst. If I approached one and no interaction icon appeared, it was a genuine moment of relief.
It was too much. Far, far too much. I’d happily have accepted the game being an hour shorter if it meant never dragging another crate. The same goes for the climbing, shimmying, and jumping. Aside from their average execution, these sections felt like traditional puzzles had been cut and replaced with the drudgery of a very slow action game. There was rarely a point to them beyond making progress harder... usually through boredom.
The sneak mechanic fares no better. Some of the most frustrating moments involved sneaking around armed guards in a temple, timing your movements to avoid getting shot while inching your way across the screen. Worse still, once you finally reached the other side, the game often sent you back to do it all again to solve the next part of the puzzle. Frustration levels steadily rising…
If I had to single out my least favourite element, though, it would be quick-time events.
I hate them. Sorry, I really do. They weren’t especially difficult, none took more than a couple of attempts, but their very presence was off-putting.
On a more positive note, I enjoyed the villains, all of them, and the late-game twist was nicely handled. It was good to see recurring characters and so many call-backs to the original adventure, while the new characters felt very much in classic Revolution style. Plenty of cheeky winks and one-liners pop up throughout the dialogue, raising both smiles and memories, which I have absolutely no problem with.
As I’ve mentioned before, the fixed camera angles could work against you, particularly in tighter spaces, and more than once I only accidentally discovered that there was more to explore in an area than first appeared.
The GOG version replaces mouse or controller input with keyboard controls. This worked reasonably well most of the time, but could lead to some awkward input errors during sneaking sections or quick-time events. Not game-breaking, but definitely annoying.
It doesn’t sound like I liked it, does it?
Yes, Broken Sword 3 has plenty of problems, and yes, a lot of frustration comes from the design choices the developers made. But for the time, it’s understandable. Revolution were clearly trying to appeal to the growing 3D action-adventure crowd, for better or worse, and assumed borrowing those mechanics was the way to do it.
Overall, though, there was enough here to keep me playing right through to the end. It was genuinely enjoyable following another chapter in George and Nico’s story, and the overall narrative of this instalment holds together very well. Not everything worked... but enough did to make it a worthy addition to the saga.
If I were to be so arrogant as to rate it, I’d give it a 6 out of 10. If I were that arrogant.
Now, on to Broken Sword 4: The Angel of Death. I’ve heard mixed things about this one, and knowing in advance that George and Nico wouldn’t have any new adventures for quite a few years afterwards doesn’t exactly fill me with confidence. Still, only time, and gameplay, will tell.
I first tried Broken Sword 3: The Sleeping Dragon on its original release, but never got very far. A combination of blocky 3D graphics, awkward camera angles, and frustrating controls saw my attempts to thwart the Sleeping Dragon quickly ebb away until, eventually, I stopped playing altogether. When Broken Sword 4: The Angel of Death arrived a few years later, I didn’t even bother to check it out... the memory of the third episode had been that disappointing.
Now, with a few more years behind me and a shift in focus from player to player-creator, I decided it was time to give it another go. The fact that it was on sale on GOG didn’t hurt either...
So, twenty-odd years later, I finally finished the game. Below are my thoughts.
What a shock to the system those basic 3D models were back in 2003. With the benefit of a couple of decades, however, they’re not quite as bad as I remember. Well… not quite anyway.
The first thing I noticed this time around was the silky tones of Rolf Saxon, once again providing the personality of our everyman hero, George Stobbart. Nico Collard, unfortunately, didn’t enjoy the same continuity. In this instalment she’s voiced by Sarah Crook, who nonetheless does a good job of injecting her with some much-needed personality. With our leads established, the game can begin — but first, let’s head back to those graphics.
I actually liked the 3D model for George. His face and expressions felt like a strong 3D interpretation of his classic 2D look. He emoted well, and even his stubble was nicely handled (especially when contrasted with the higher-resolution but oddly worse face model in Broken Sword 4).
Nico, however, was not so lucky. Leaving aside for the moment her massive, sealed-at-the-end nostrils, there were so many issues with her arms and legs that I started to suspect she’d once been involved in a locomotive crash and escaped hospital before being properly discharged. Hands twisted at impossible angles, a neck that seemed only loosely attached to her head, and even her 90s flared trousers couldn’t contain those janky feet. It was obvious far more care had been taken with George’s model, something that extended to most of the supporting cast (Petra especially). None of this is game-breaking, the comfortable cushion of “playing an old game” helps a lot, but it reminded me exactly why I wasn’t impressed the first time around.
Thankfully, the game itself tells a solid story spanning several continents, as you’d expect. I enjoyed poking around a hugely empty Glastonbury (if only the real Glastonbury was as easy to get around), where I felt some of the game’s best puzzles lived, and the Congo sections had a nice overall feel, injecting a bit of classic Indy-style exploration. Puzzles that required both characters to work in tandem were a great addition, and I particularly liked the tiled floor puzzle in the Omega Temple section.
However… crates.
With the success of Tomb Raider and other 3D adventure games, a lot of time here is spent pushing crates backwards and forwards. I mean, really a lot. At first it was a novelty, “Okay, this is new for a Broken Sword game.” Eventually, though, every time I entered a new area and spotted a crate, I would tense up and expect the worst. If I approached one and no interaction icon appeared, it was a genuine moment of relief.
It was too much. Far, far too much. I’d happily have accepted the game being an hour shorter if it meant never dragging another crate. The same goes for the climbing, shimmying, and jumping. Aside from their average execution, these sections felt like traditional puzzles had been cut and replaced with the drudgery of a very slow action game. There was rarely a point to them beyond making progress harder... usually through boredom.
The sneak mechanic fares no better. Some of the most frustrating moments involved sneaking around armed guards in a temple, timing your movements to avoid getting shot while inching your way across the screen. Worse still, once you finally reached the other side, the game often sent you back to do it all again to solve the next part of the puzzle. Frustration levels steadily rising…
If I had to single out my least favourite element, though, it would be quick-time events.
I hate them. Sorry, I really do. They weren’t especially difficult, none took more than a couple of attempts, but their very presence was off-putting.
On a more positive note, I enjoyed the villains, all of them, and the late-game twist was nicely handled. It was good to see recurring characters and so many call-backs to the original adventure, while the new characters felt very much in classic Revolution style. Plenty of cheeky winks and one-liners pop up throughout the dialogue, raising both smiles and memories, which I have absolutely no problem with.
As I’ve mentioned before, the fixed camera angles could work against you, particularly in tighter spaces, and more than once I only accidentally discovered that there was more to explore in an area than first appeared.
The GOG version replaces mouse or controller input with keyboard controls. This worked reasonably well most of the time, but could lead to some awkward input errors during sneaking sections or quick-time events. Not game-breaking, but definitely annoying.
It doesn’t sound like I liked it, does it?
Yes, Broken Sword 3 has plenty of problems, and yes, a lot of frustration comes from the design choices the developers made. But for the time, it’s understandable. Revolution were clearly trying to appeal to the growing 3D action-adventure crowd, for better or worse, and assumed borrowing those mechanics was the way to do it.
Overall, though, there was enough here to keep me playing right through to the end. It was genuinely enjoyable following another chapter in George and Nico’s story, and the overall narrative of this instalment holds together very well. Not everything worked... but enough did to make it a worthy addition to the saga.
If I were to be so arrogant as to rate it, I’d give it a 6 out of 10. If I were that arrogant.
Now, on to Broken Sword 4: The Angel of Death. I’ve heard mixed things about this one, and knowing in advance that George and Nico wouldn’t have any new adventures for quite a few years afterwards doesn’t exactly fill me with confidence. Still, only time, and gameplay, will tell.
Wild Boar 01-03-2026, 05:39 PM
Has the game always been this bad? There are some things that should be kept as fond memories and never touched again.
You click and click and click just to get Kate to move a little bit. Even on paths where you can only go forward, sometimes twice in quick succession. And then there's the endless road in the village...
If I don't stop now, I'll get mouse arm. If I ever get my hands on a Steam Deck or a controller, I'll try again, but not before then.
You click and click and click just to get Kate to move a little bit. Even on paths where you can only go forward, sometimes twice in quick succession. And then there's the endless road in the village...
If I don't stop now, I'll get mouse arm. If I ever get my hands on a Steam Deck or a controller, I'll try again, but not before then.
Joshua AGH 12-31-2025, 04:06 PM
In this video myself, Jack and many of our staff pour out our soul offering a heartfelt thank you while looking back on the genre in 2025.
I focus on th incredible contributions from our incredible staff. Jack looks back on the games of 2025 while Johnny, Micah, Sean and Sam gush about their experiences in adventure gaming in 2025.
Lets spread the love in this thread.
I focus on th incredible contributions from our incredible staff. Jack looks back on the games of 2025 while Johnny, Micah, Sean and Sam gush about their experiences in adventure gaming in 2025.
Lets spread the love in this thread.
Piero 12-31-2025, 11:50 AM
What are your favourite 3 games of all time, from any genre?
I'll kick off:
Recent: The Witness
Older: Shenmue
Childhood: Captain Blood (on the Amstrad CPC)
I'll kick off:
Recent: The Witness
Older: Shenmue
Childhood: Captain Blood (on the Amstrad CPC)
Wild Boar 12-30-2025, 06:58 PM
Surely a strange question from someone who doesn't have a favorite food, color, or anything else. (I believe that all things have their place and are too different to rank.)
What were your favorite adventures and games in 2025?
Mine were The Drifter and The Lost Crown, and even though I see The Drifter in the lead.
Best games: The Drifter, Herdling, and Winter Burrow, with Herdling at the top of my list: But as I already wrote: You simply can't compare the games
Is "Best adventures / games, you have played in 2025" oder Best adventures / games, you played in 2025" right? I am not sure.
What were your favorite adventures and games in 2025?
Mine were The Drifter and The Lost Crown, and even though I see The Drifter in the lead.
Best games: The Drifter, Herdling, and Winter Burrow, with Herdling at the top of my list: But as I already wrote: You simply can't compare the games
Is "Best adventures / games, you have played in 2025" oder Best adventures / games, you played in 2025" right? I am not sure.
Joshua AGH 12-29-2025, 04:31 PM
Did we miss any? We'd love to hear your games and the order in which you'd have ranked them.
https://adventuregamehotspot.com/feature...-2000-2025
https://adventuregamehotspot.com/feature...-2000-2025
jbh 12-28-2025, 03:22 PM
What colour is it? It's referred to in-game as purple, but it looks more like pink to me. It's also been rendered as greenish-blue, and orange. Maybe I'm missing some? Anyway, what colour is the sky of Kerona to YOU? I'm curious to hear what people think!
BobVP 12-27-2025, 01:44 PM
A text adventure playthrough works like this: the leader plays the game and shares the output with the players. The players propose input by posting a response in the thread. They can also discuss the game and decide on a course of action in these posts.
Let's start with a couple of suggestions. If anyone wants to lead a playthrough: great! If not, I'll lead the first one.
As a first suggestion: Wishbringer, by Brian Moriarty.
https://ifdb.org/viewgame?id=z02joykzh66wfhcl
Let's start with a couple of suggestions. If anyone wants to lead a playthrough: great! If not, I'll lead the first one.
As a first suggestion: Wishbringer, by Brian Moriarty.
https://ifdb.org/viewgame?id=z02joykzh66wfhcl
Jackal 12-24-2025, 08:58 PM
Hey, all.
Just wanted to wish everyone a Merry Christmas and/or Happy Holidays, on behalf of the entire Hotspot team!
To help mark the occasion, we've brought back an annual tradition to bring you a video full of personal season's greetings from this year's (or any year's!) top developers. Plus a very special musical surprise at the end!
Thanks to all of you for being part of the Hotspot family. It's been a great year for adventure gaming, and we're glad to have you be a part of it!
Just wanted to wish everyone a Merry Christmas and/or Happy Holidays, on behalf of the entire Hotspot team!
To help mark the occasion, we've brought back an annual tradition to bring you a video full of personal season's greetings from this year's (or any year's!) top developers. Plus a very special musical surprise at the end!
Thanks to all of you for being part of the Hotspot family. It's been a great year for adventure gaming, and we're glad to have you be a part of it!
Welcome, Guest
There are currently 97 online users. 0 Member(s) | 91 Guest(s)
Applebot, Baidu, Bing, DuckDuckGo, Facebook, Google
Latest Threads
Adventure game scene game...
Forum: Adventure GamesLast Post: HitBattousai, 10 hours ago
Replies: 2,241 - Views: 436,692
Artheria – a quiet fantas...
Forum: Adventure GamesLast Post: HoschiBro, Yesterday, 11:30 PM
Replies: 1 - Views: 239
New Space Quest?! Well, s...
Forum: Adventure GamesLast Post: Josh_Mandel, Yesterday, 07:01 PM
Replies: 13 - Views: 1,166
Bimonthly Adventure Game ...
Forum: Adventure GamesLast Post: Nad_venture, 11-20-2026, 12:27 PM
Replies: 0 - Views: 113
KOBALT – The Legacy of th...
Forum: Adventure GamesLast Post: BobVP, 11-19-2026, 07:53 PM
Replies: 3 - Views: 209
Edited post message time ...
Forum: Site FeedbackLast Post: Piero, 11-19-2026, 07:10 PM
Replies: 2 - Views: 381
Following Freeware/Pay-Wh...
Forum: Adventure GamesLast Post: BobVP, 11-19-2026, 07:03 PM
Replies: 63 - Views: 19,730
What Adventure Games are ...
Forum: Adventure GamesLast Post: Geisterfaust, 11-19-2026, 07:03 AM
Replies: 212 - Views: 66,886
Which SOUND-BASED PUZZLE ...
Forum: Adventure GamesLast Post: LadyKestrel, 11-17-2026, 03:16 PM
Replies: 9 - Views: 521
AI has taken over….
Forum: Adventure GamesLast Post: Piero, 11-17-2026, 10:01 AM
Replies: 30 - Views: 2,015